Markets

Homes Sold Per Capita: A Turnover Leaderboard and What It Does (and Doesn't) Do for Storage Rents

Nobody publishes 'homes sold per capita,' so I built it: Redfin metro sales ÷ Census population, 2023–2025, top 100 whole-MSA markets. Florida owns the leaderboard. Then I ran it against three years of 10x10 street rates in 26 markets. The highest-turnover markets saw rents fall the most. Turnover tells you where demand comes from, not where rents go. Supply chases the same signal.

Stay in touch

Follow the business, or ask about investing.

Both paths go to a principal rather than a sales desk.

Interested investors are also added to the market letter. Choose Newsletter only if you want the letter without being contacted about opportunities.

Back to Learn
July 12, 2026/By Armand Aghadjanians, Director of Acquisitions

24.2

homes sold per 1,000 residents in North Port–Sarasota, FL, the highest of the 100 largest whole-MSA markets

7 of 8

top turnover metros are in Florida

−17%

street-rate change in high-turnover markets, H2-23 → H1-26

−2%

same measure in the lowest-turnover markets

0.58

correlation between the CHANGE in national housing turnover and the CHANGE in average storage REIT occupancy, 2006 to 2025, on a 0-to-1 scale where 1 is lockstep

Industry gospel says moves fill units. A home sale is two moving events: a seller packing out, a buyer packing in. So the metros with the most sales per resident should be the best storage markets. I tested it.

  • The stat: homes sold per 1,000 residents. Redfin metro sales ÷ Census population, 2023–2025 average, across the 100 largest whole-MSA markets. Nobody publishes this number, so I built it.
  • The test: 36 months of TractIQ 10x10 street rates across a 26-market sample from the top, middle, and bottom of the ranking.
  • The result: the highest-turnover markets had the worst rate trend. Turnover finds demand. It doesn't find rent growth.

What this is

Personal research, not investment advice. Sales counts are Redfin MLS-recorded transactions (they differ from NAR and deed-based counts); population is Census Vintage 2025. Large metros Redfin splits into custom sub-metro divisions (NYC, LA, Chicago, DC, Boston, Miami, Philadelphia, Dallas, San Francisco, Seattle, Detroit) are excluded from the top-100 ranking because their boundaries can't be matched to Census geography. LA and NY re-enter the rate sample as approximations. Street rates and all supply figures (sq ft per capita, construction pipeline) are TractIQ pulls within a 25-mile radius of each metro core. A fixed radius is a submarket sample, not full-MSA coverage: it clips large metros and can pull in neighboring counties, so treat those numbers as directional and cross-market comparisons as same-basis, not exact. Turnover figures are full-MSA. Rate and turnover figures computed July 12, 2026; supply figures July 23, 2026.

The turnover leaderboard

Chart

Where America buys the most homes per capita

Homes sold per 1,000 residents, 2023–2025 average. Top 10 of the 100 largest whole-MSA metros.

0510152025North Port–Sarasota, FLCape Coral–Ft. Myers, FLDeltona–Daytona, FLPalm Bay–Melbourne, FLCharleston, SCPort St. Lucie, FLPensacola, FLLakeland, FLFayetteville, ARHuntsville, AL24.222.519.518.418.218.217.917.417.416.8

Seven of the top eight are in Florida. Boise (16.8), Tampa (16.4), Jacksonville (16.1) and Nashville (15.2) round out the top 14.

Source: Redfin Data Center metro tracker (All Residential, non-seasonally-adjusted homes sold) ÷ US Census Bureau MSA population estimates (Vintage 2025). Author's calculation, July 2026.

  • Sarasota's 24.2 means the number of homes sold each year equals 2.4% of the entire population — not of households, of people. In a slow national market.
  • Seven of the top eight metros are in Florida. Charleston is the only outsider.
  • Bottom of the table: San Diego (7.2), San Jose (6.0), Fresno (5.4), McAllen (4.7). LA (5.4) and New York (5.7), reconstructed from Redfin's sub-metro divisions, land in the same band.
  • A Sarasota resident is 4–5x more likely to be part of a home sale in a given year than a resident of LA or New York.

The test: 26 markets, three groups

Not a random sample. I overweighted the extremes, where a relationship would be most visible:

  • High turnover, 15+ per 1k (n=14): Sarasota 24.2, Cape Coral 22.5, Daytona 19.5, Palm Bay–Melbourne 18.4, Charleston 18.2, Port St. Lucie 18.2, Pensacola 17.9, Lakeland 17.4, Fayetteville AR 17.4, Huntsville 16.8, Boise 16.8, Tampa 16.4, Jacksonville 16.1, Nashville 15.2.
  • Mid turnover, 10–15 (n=6): San Antonio 12.1, Birmingham 12.0, Austin 11.9, Tulsa 11.9, Louisville 11.8, Columbus OH 11.8. Ranks 45–60; skews Sun Belt/Midwest for clean whole-MSA data and facility density.
  • Low turnover, under 10 (n=6): San Diego 7.2, San Jose 6.0, New York 5.7, Los Angeles 5.4, Fresno 5.4, McAllen 4.7. LA and NY are division-sum approximations.

What this sample can and can't support

26 of 100 markets, weighted to the extremes. The right shape for detecting whether a relationship exists, and the wrong shape for quoting the correlations as if they covered all 100 metros. Fresno and McAllen have thin facility samples; treat their individual trends as indicative. Directional evidence, not a controlled study.

What the street rates show

Chart

The higher the turnover, the worse the rate trend

Average 10x10 street-rate change, H2 2023 → H1 2026, by turnover group

High turnover (15+/1k), n=14Mid turnover (10–15), n=6Low turnover (<10), n=6-20%-15%-10%-5%0%Percent-16.6%-11.7%-1.7%

Across the 26 markets, the correlation between turnover and rate change is about −0.56. Cape Coral (−35%), Daytona (−34%) and Sarasota (−30%), the top three turnover markets in America, posted the worst declines in the sample.

Source: TractIQ pricing trends, 10x10 units, climate + non-climate, facility-weighted, 25-mile radius of each metro core. Author's calculation, July 2026.

Chart

Market by market: the leaders fell hardest, the locked-in coasts held

10x10 street-rate change, H2 2023 → H1 2026, selected markets. 25-mile radius of each metro core.

-36%-27%-18%-9%0%9%Cape CoralDaytonaSarasotaSan AntonioHuntsvilleTampaNashvilleCharlestonNew YorkBoisePort St. LucieLos AngelesJacksonvilleSan Jose-35.2%-34.2%-30.4%-28.6%-23%-17.5%-7.9%-7.9%-7.2%-4.5%-2.3%0.4%1.3%6.5%

Port St. Lucie is the exception: top-six turnover, rates essentially flat and rising through mid-2026. The supply numbers behind it are in the bullets below.

Source: TractIQ pricing trends, 25-mile radius of each metro core, author's calculation, July 2026.

  • Turnover vs. rate change, 26 markets: correlation of −0.56. The three highest-turnover markets in America posted the three worst declines.
  • Turnover vs. rate level: also −0.56. High-turnover markets have cheaper storage, not pricier.
  • Levels: LA $2.58, New York $2.58, San Diego $2.13 per sq ft/month. The high-turnover Sun Belt clusters at $0.75–$1.60.
  • That's not a turnover effect. It's land cost and supply constraint. The same forces that block housing on the coasts block storage, and rents on both show it.

How both signals can be right

  • Nationally, over time, turnover does drive storage demand. Sell-side research cited by Nareit (Dec 2025) puts the correlation between the change in housing turnover and the change in average REIT occupancy at 0.58 for 2006–2025. (Correlation: 0 means no relationship, 1 means the two move in lockstep. 0.58 is a solid link.)
  • Total home sales (new plus existing) were running about 4.4 million annualized in late 2025, down 36% from the Q4 2020 peak. Per the same Nareit piece, rents charged to new customers had only just turned positive year-over-year for the first time in about two and a half years.
  • At the market level, everyone sees the same signal, and developers chased the exact metros at the top of this leaderboard.
  • Yardi Matrix (June 2026): the Sarasota–Cape Coral corridor still carries a construction pipeline at 5.2% of existing stock, years into the rate correction. 28 of Yardi's top 30 metros were still posting year-over-year declines in non-climate-controlled street rates as of May 2026.
  • The same report ties Texas's prolonged weakness to fading migration and home sales after the 2021–22 boom.

The one-sentence version

Homes sold per capita tells you where storage demand comes from. It does not tell you where storage rents are going, because rents are set by demand AND supply. And supply chases the same headline you do.

  • One more nuance: in retiree-heavy Florida metros, a big share of transactions are inbound retirees and second-home buyers. Storage-intensive once, and a magnet for new development.
  • Port St. Lucie is the exception worth studying. It was the only high-turnover Florida market where rates were still climbing through mid-2026, after a shallow three-year decline of just −2.3%. (Jacksonville, at +1.3%, is the only Florida market in the sample with a positive three-year change.)
  • Why it held, in numbers. Measured within a 25-mile radius of each metro core (TractIQ, July 2026; a submarket cut, not full-MSA, per the methodology note up top): Port St. Lucie has 7.5 sq ft of storage per person, vs 10.0 in Sarasota and 8.7 in Cape Coral. The least existing supply per capita of the three, with top-six turnover feeding demand.
  • The caveat: its pipeline is no longer light. 1.5M sq ft in TractIQ's construction pipeline in the same 25-mile radius, about 26% of existing stock, proportionally more than Sarasota (20%) or Cape Coral (17%). (TractIQ's pipeline measure is broader than Yardi's under-construction-only figure; compare across markets, not against the 5.2% above.) The exception is about to be tested.

What I'd do with this

  • Use homes sold per capita as a demand-side screen, not a buy signal. The top of the list is stable year to year.
  • Then underwrite supply just as hard: existing sq ft per capita, pipeline as % of stock, deliveries over the past 36 months. Measure them on full-MSA or trade-area boundaries when you can; my 25-mile-radius cut is the quick screen, not the underwrite.
  • The target profile is high turnover plus disciplined supply. The Port St. Lucie of 2023–2025, not Cape Coral.
  • When a high-turnover market digests its supply wave, the demand engine is still there. Southwest Florida's depressed 2025–26 street rates are a cyclical price on a structurally busy market.

What I'd watch to confirm or kill the thesis

(1) Sarasota/Cape Coral pipeline as % of stock: below 3% means the digestion phase is ending. (2) Street-rate YoY in the high-turnover group turning positive while turnover holds 15+ per 1k: the demand engine reasserting. (3) Port St. Lucie holding its recent rate momentum as its own 26%-of-stock pipeline delivers: the live test of the high-turnover, disciplined-supply profile.


Sources

RHW CapitalManagement Group

An experienced owner-operator of self storage. ISS Top Operator, 2015–2025.

Store Here Self Storage
SiteHawk Remote Management Solutions

Headquarters

1820 W. Orangewood Ave
Suite 203
Orange, CA 92868

© 2026 RHW Capital Management Group, LLC. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy

This website describes RHW Capital Management Group's self storage ownership, operations, and third party management services. Nothing on it is an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security. RHW Capital Management Group offerings are made under Rule 506(b) of Regulation D, without general solicitation, and only to accredited investors with whom RHW has a pre-existing substantive relationship, through definitive offering documents. RHW Capital Management Group does not operate a continuously offered fund; each investment is a separate, deal-specific offering, and any performance shown reflects past, fully realized deals. Operating results described here reflect specific properties and periods and are not a prediction of results at any other property.