REITs

The Supply-Led Recovery: What the Big-3 Told Us in Q3 2026

Q3 2026 was the quarter the numbers started agreeing with each other. Big-3 same-store NOI turned up 2.2%, in-place rents are growing again, and move-outs have fallen five straight quarters. Demand didn't come roaring back. Supply stopped showing up. My 34-slide deck is free to download.

Free download

The full Q3 2026 deck

34 slides, every chart from the video.

Download PDF (2.9 MB)Watch on YouTube

Stay in touch

Follow the business, or ask about investing.

Both paths go to a principal rather than a sales desk.

Interested investors are also added to the market letter. Choose Newsletter only if you want the letter without being contacted about opportunities.

Back to Learn
November 6, 2026/By Armand Aghadjanians, Director of Acquisitions

+2.2%

Big-3 same-store NOI growth, Q3 2026, revenue-weighted

+1.6%

Big-3 in-place rent growth, year over year

-3.4%

Big-3 move-outs, the fifth straight quarterly decline

16.5 mo

Public Storage implied average length of stay, up from about 13.5 before COVID

~half

Forecast cut in new completions this cycle, vs -80% after the GFC

Four times a year Public Storage, Extra Space and CubeSmart open their books. They're the three largest storage REITs, and because they're public they have to disclose far more than any private operator ever will. So every quarter I pull their supplements apart and roll them into one revenue-weighted number I call the Big-3 Composite. They operate in different markets and run their platforms differently, and I don't care about any single print. I want the trend line.

Right now the trend line says we're coming out of the trough. I went through all 34 slides on YouTube. This is the written version, and the full deck is at the bottom of the page.

NOI turned positive, and it wasn't revenue that broke it

The Big-3 Composite bottomed in Q3 2024 and has been climbing back toward zero since. Same-store NOI growth followed. After two years of small negatives, the Big-3 printed +2.2% in Q3 2026, the first meaningful positive number since 2023. I like to see 2%. I'd love to see a couple of quarters at 3% or better. To me that's the signal of a full-fledged recovery.

What people miss is where the pain came from. Revenue went flat in 2024 and 2025, but it didn't collapse. Expenses did the damage. From 2023 through 2025, expenses alone took 0.7 to 1.7 points off NOI growth every single quarter. Property taxes were the biggest drag, then marketing. Insurance hurt too. Storage is a good inflation hedge on the revenue side, but we pay our own expenses too, and in 2024 and 2025 they caught up with us. We had sites paying about $20,000 a year in property insurance that more than doubled, and they weren't coastal markets.

Guidance went up all year

Public Storage opened 2026 guiding to an NOI decline of 2.2%. That was scary. My read at the time was a new CEO setting a bar he could clear, and that's roughly what happened. By October, all three had raised their NOI guidance:

  • Public Storage: −2.2% to −0.3%
  • Extra Space: −0.5% to +3.0%
  • CubeSmart: −0.75% to +0.4%

Revenue guidance went up and expense guidance came down at all three. Both sides of the ledger are moving in the right direction at the same time.

Table

2026 same-store guidance midpoints: with Q1 results vs October

Each cell reads Q1 guide → October guide

CompanyRevenueExpensesNOI
Public Storage-1.1% → +0.25%+2.15% → +2.0%-2.2% → -0.3%
Extra Space+0.5% → +2.25%+2.75% → +0.25%-0.5% → +3.0%
CubeSmart+0.5% → +1.2%+4.0% → +3.3%-0.75% → +0.4%

Source: Company earnings releases. PSA's expense guide covers direct cost of operations.

Rents: existing customers up, new customers still getting a deal

Big-3 in-place rent growth turned positive in 2026 and sits at +1.6% year over year. It isn't moving in a meaningful way yet, but it's moving the right way.

The gap between what new and existing customers pay is still wide. At Public Storage a new customer pays $14.66 per square foot. The average existing customer pays $22.75. On a trailing basis, PSA's move-in rents are back to 2012–13 levels. Think about how bad the economy was back then. If you're renting a unit for one to three months today, you're getting a very good deal.

Existing-customer rate increases have caused friction, and the industry has mostly worked through it with better disclosures. The good news is that move-in rates have started turning positive, especially at Public Storage, even while move-in volumes are falling.

Tenants are staying longer

Move-ins are down. Move-outs are down more. Big-3 move-outs have fallen year over year for five straight quarters, which means the customer is staying longer. Public Storage's implied average length of stay is 16.5 months, up from about 13.5 before COVID. Forget COVID, it was an anomaly. Today's tenant is simply a longer-term renter.

The reason is in the demand mix. The Self Storage Association's demand studies show a record 12.6% of households renting storage in 2024. Millennials and urban renters gained the most. Between the 2022 and 2025 studies, "while changing residence" fell 5 points as a reason to rent. "Items no longer needed or wanted" rose 5. "No room at residence" is still the largest at 46%.

Chart

Why people rent: 2022 vs 2025 SSA study

% of renters, multiple answers allowed

2022 study
2025 study
0%15%30%55%No room at residenceItems no longerneeded or wantedWhile changingresidenceRelative's items(living change)Inherited itemsWhile away fromresidenceWhile remodeling

Source: Self Storage Association 2022 and 2025 Demand Studies, Figure 2-25. Survey margin about 2 pts.

That's the frozen housing market showing up in our data. People aren't moving, but life keeps going. You have a two-bedroom townhouse, a second kid arrives, and you can't afford the upgrade. You still need somewhere to put the overflow. That kind of demand takes years to build, and it's a stickier customer than the one who rents for a 60-day move.

Chart

Move-outs are falling faster than move-ins

Big-3 same-store move-ins and move-outs, YoY %, revenue-weighted

Move-ins
Move-outs
Q4'23Q1'24Q2'24Q3'24Q4'24Q1'25Q2'25Q3'25Q4'25Q1'26Q2'26Q3'26-6%-4%-2%0%2%

Source: Company quarterly supplements, Q4 2023 to Q3 2026. Big-3 weighted by same-store revenue. PSA in sq ft.

Every market is its own story

National numbers hide a lot. I track 11 metros that all three REITs report consistently, because the sequence matters. When markets start separating from each other, or start moving in the same direction together, that's the cyclical transition I watch for.

Tampa is the clearest example. Hurricanes Helene and Milton damaged a lot of storage in late 2024. That temporarily took supply off the market at the same moment the community needed somewhere to put its belongings. Revenue jumped, and I posted at the time that it was a temporary demand surge. It was. Homes got rebuilt, people moved on, and Tampa's same-store revenue has slid back to between −1.6% and −6.9% depending on the REIT. Yardi has 36-month deliveries in Tampa at 17.5% of existing stock.

Across all 11 metros, the more new supply a market took in, the weaker its revenue. The correlation is −0.57. Chicago, New York and Washington DC barely built and are growing. Tampa, Orlando, Atlanta and Houston built heavily and are still negative. Outside of Tampa and parts of DC, though, the major metros are starting to turn positive together, and occupancy by metro has ticked up slightly in 2026.

In management's own words

From the Q3 2026 earnings calls:

"So it really seems to be more of a supply moderation story than a demand recovery story."
Jeff Norman, CFO, Extra Space
"As we exit 2026, confidence is building that we are moving from stabilization to gradual recovery."
Tom Boyle, CEO, Public Storage
"It's hard to justify putting a shovel in the ground in many places."
Christopher Marr, CEO, CubeSmart

I agree with all three. The direction was never really the question. The question is when, and by how much.

Supply is the whole story

There's plenty of literature on how well storage did after the Great Financial Crisis. The reason wasn't demand. Credit froze, nobody could finance a new building, and national completions fell about 80%. That gave the industry room to breathe. Extra Space's same-store NOI went from a −7.9% low to +8.5% by 2014 while construction collapsed underneath it. After the GFC, occupancy rose 2 to 3 points a year for four years, and metro revenue recovered with no help from housing.

Will supply fall that hard this time? Probably not. Nobody thinks the financial system is about to collapse. But building is very hard to pencil right now. Rents are down, construction costs are up, and projects take years from plan to delivery. The 2024 and 2025 deliveries were mostly deals planned around 2020 and 2021. Yardi's forecast has completions falling about half from the 2025 peak by 2028.

There's one important difference from 2009. Back then expenses were flat, which let NOI beat revenue. From 2023 to 2025 it was the reverse. Operators have been working hard to get expenses under control, and you can see it in the 2026 guidance. That's a big pivot point for NOI over the next several quarters.

Table

Extra Space same-store growth, %: GFC aftermath vs past 5 years

Expense cells are shaded light red when expenses rose. 2008* = nine months.

GFC aftermath, 2008 to 2014Past 5 years
2008*20092010201120122013201420212022202320242025TTM
Revenue+2.0-3.6+1.7+4.5+6.2+6.9+7.0+14+17+3.1+0.2+0.1+1.8
Expenses-0.1-0.3-1.40.0-1.2+1.9+3.0-1.0+8.8+4.0+5.7+4.9+0.3
NOI+3.1-5.4+3.4+6.9+10+9.3+8.8+20+20+2.8-1.5-1.7+2.4

Source: Extra Space supplements; expenses exclude tenant reinsurance and management fees.

What I'm watching

The maturity wall. A lot of facilities were bought or refinanced in 2021 and 2022 at peak valuations, with low rates and five-year terms. Add modifications and extensions, and those loans are coming due now. CMBS is only a sliver of storage lending, but it's the sliver we can see, and a big share of what's maturing sits below the roughly 10% debt yield lenders want. An owner in that spot has to bring cash to refinance. Sometimes that's a few hundred thousand dollars, sometimes millions. That's what forces sellers to meet the market, and I expect a lot more listings over the next few years.

A 3% print. I want to see Big-3 same-store NOI hold above 3% for a couple of quarters.

Markets moving together. When nearly every metro moves in one direction, that's when cycles pivot. You can already see columns in Extra Space's Q3 supplement where everything points the same way.

None of this happens overnight. There's no ticker that reprices a storage facility minute by minute, and the recovery after the GFC took years. But for the first time in a long time, the numbers agree with each other.

Download the full deck

Self-Storage Q3 2026: The Supply-Led Recovery. 34 slides, every chart from the video, with sources on each slide.

Watch the walkthrough on YouTube
Download PDF (2.9 MB)

Sources

Sources

  • Public Storage, Extra Space Storage and CubeSmart quarterly supplemental disclosures and earnings releases, through Q3 2026
  • Q3 2026 earnings call transcripts (PSA Oct 27, EXR Oct 28, CUBE Oct 30, 2026)
  • Self Storage Association 2022 and 2025 Self Storage Demand Studies
  • Yardi Matrix, National Self Storage Report (Oct 2026) and Fall 2026 National Outlook
  • Storable Industry Pulse
  • Public Storage and Extra Space 10-Ks; US Census, value of mini-storage construction put in place
  • NAR existing-home sales; Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey

For educational and informational purposes only. Nothing here is an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security, and nothing here is investment, legal or tax advice. Figures are as reported by each source and have not been audited. Composite and implied length-of-stay figures are my own calculations.

RHW CapitalManagement Group

An experienced owner-operator of self storage. ISS Top Operator, 2015–2025.

Store Here Self Storage
SiteHawk Remote Management Solutions

Headquarters

1820 W. Orangewood Ave
Suite 203
Orange, CA 92868

© 2026 RHW Capital Management Group, LLC. All rights reserved.

Privacy Policy

This website describes RHW Capital Management Group's self storage ownership, operations, and third party management services. Nothing on it is an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security. RHW Capital Management Group offerings are made under Rule 506(b) of Regulation D, without general solicitation, and only to accredited investors with whom RHW has a pre-existing substantive relationship, through definitive offering documents. RHW Capital Management Group does not operate a continuously offered fund; each investment is a separate, deal-specific offering, and any performance shown reflects past, fully realized deals. Operating results described here reflect specific properties and periods and are not a prediction of results at any other property.